Security and Safety for 2nd Passport Citizenship Investments

 

Search for A Safe Place to Live is A Fast Growing Trend  

 

The value of having a secure and stable place to live, is a privilege many of us overlook and undervalue. Having a safe place to live in peaceful retirement, or to grow a family and prosper, is a priority. Attaining this security is a growing concern for people in a growing number of locations, as global geo-political tensions increase daily…. The investment in a secure place to live is gaining a higher priority ranking in financial planning for a growing proportion of the world’s affluent population.

 

My friend Shazia is a good example. Her husband’s parents are looking for alternative residency due to recent border tensions in their home country. For many people enduring this dilemma, the solutions are to obtain residency in a different country, or to obtain a second passport.

 

Citizenship Programs: Unusual ‘Investment’ Characteristics

For 2^nd passports, thankfully there are many options available, but only if n applicant possess a fairly substantial capital sum, in the range of $200,000 or more. These solutions are referred to as Citizenship by Investment Programs (CBI or CIP). As an investment, these programs have characteristics that are not commonly associated with the term ‘investment’.

• The first characteristic is the immediate capital write down that occurs as a result of donations or other non-refundable contributions to the recipient nation.
• The second characteristic is the high fees paid to advisors, often lacking in transparency and disclosure.
• Due to the cross-border nature of the transaction, and competing, conflicting national interests, there is little regulatory protection for investors.

 

Good Program Design Attracts Investors

Among the most successful of these citizenship programs in the last 12 months has been that of the Republic of Turkey, in terms of the number of new passports granted. The success is due to a combination of factors;

• The application process is simple and approval is practically risk free.
• The capital allocation required is low, at $250,000 for a real estate purchase, or $500,000 for bank deposits, government bonds, venture capital funds or REITS.
• The capital write down is among the lowest available, at zero: there are no donations and non non-refundable contributions….

 

Quality of Service: Advisory Consultants

Knowing of my experience with Turkish real estate, my friend Shazia reached out for my support, in response to advice received from CIP consultants, about Turkey’s Program. I agreed to do a little research. We were all surprised by the results. Of 20 CIP consultants selected from the top internet search engine rankings (including top tier international consulting firms), my survey results are as follows:

• 85% would only provide information about the real estate investment option, and not the alternatives of bank deposits or government bonds etc
• 90% of those would not provide meaningful transparency regarding due diligence on the real estate (checking prices, permits, liens, appraisals, payments and other precautions).
• More than 70% instead advised ‘we have done hundreds, don’t worry, there isn’t any risk…’ (in other words, ‘trust us’…)
• More than 80% were incapable of providing information about Turkish Lira currency devaluation rates, or property price history trends in Dollar or Euro terms.
• New passport application processing fees charged by advisors for real estate investors range from $2,500 to $7,000, but for investors in bank deposits, etc the fees range from $6,000 to $15,0000.
• Less than 5%: only one provided website and email links to Turkish government agency websites for Turkey's Citizenship Investment Program via Real Estate Purchases, Fuds, Bank Deposits, etc, which provide multiple sources of clear and accurate disclosure.

 

These results suggest the quality of service provided by advisors in the CIP / CBI sector is of a wider variance and significantly below standards generally to be expected for ‘investment’….  From the successful result of Turkey’s Citizenship by Investment program, the quality of advice is obviously not a factor deterring investors.

 

Due Diligence is Essential: Caveat Emptor

However, as a professional, and with friendly concern for my friend Shazia, I ventured further with my own due diligence.  My curiosity was piqued by the fact that advisors were charging considerably higher fees for bank deposits than for real estate investment, despite real estate requiring far more work and expense.

 

Finding the explanation did not take long…. On real estate purchases, the advisors receive non-disclosed profit sharing amounting to as much as 20% of the property sales price. In other words, there is a capital write down that is not evident to the investor until after the three year duration of the required holding period. A very clever program design feature it may be, but not a very clever use of an investor’s capital. Presumably most investors that have participated are not aware of this. That presumption also proved inaccurate, because this fact is widely lambasted on both Chinese and Arabic speaking social media. Evidently the consultants and attorneys participating in these schemes and advising enquiring investors smugly on the merits of real estate investment, imagining the investors know no better, appear a little disingenuous. And foolish too, considering they are fooling few other than themselves….

 

For Shazia’s family the search for solutions continues, now fortunately aided by an advisor that has lived in the locations he is advising about, and also understands the value of protecting investors and their capital… a trait that is sadly absent in this investment sector, and notable for that reason…

 

 

 

 

住宅房地产投资伊斯坦布尔土耳其

आवासीय अचल संपत्ति निवेश istanbul टर्की है

no tax citizenship investment istanbul turkey

免税公民投资伊斯坦布尔土耳其

कोई टैक्स नागरिकता निवेश इतनबुल टर्की नहीं है

#citizenship #investment #immigration #CitizenshipInvestment #Turkey #CitizenshipbyInvestment #bankdeposits #governmentbonds #PropertyTurkey #RealEstate #currencyrisk #TL #risk #cip #cbi #citizenshipinvestmentturkey  #2ndpassport #notax #immigrationservices #residency #residencybyinvestment #businessinvestor #realestateinvestor #passports #turkey #citizenshipbyinvestment #immigration #residency #passports #turkish #travel #tax  #2ndpassport #citizenship #immigration #taxlaws #InvestmentstrategyTurkey #RealEstateResearchTurkey #RealEstateResearchIstanbul #IstanbulInvestmentstrategy #mytapu #investturkey #citizenshipinvestmentTurkey

#Turkey #foreigninvestmentpromotion

 

2-ші төлқұжаттар азаматтық инвестициялау Түркия

2de paspoorte burgerskap belegging turkiye

#第二本护照 #公民投资土耳其 #伊斯坦布尔  2-ші төлқұжаттар  # 2-й паспорт гражданство-Турции-инвестиции # 2 ਪਾਸਪੋਰਟ  ਨਾਗਰਿਕਤਾ ਨਿਵੇਸ਼ ਟਰਕੀ नागरिकता निवेश तुर्की  दूसरा पासपोर्ट

   2 جوازات السفر 2nd پاسپورٽ   2ھريت سيڙپڪاري

 ترڪي

دوسرا پاسپورٹدوهم پاسپورټونه المواطنة الاستثمار تركيا  د تابعیت پانګه ترکیه

سرمایه گذاری شهروندی ترکیه

شہریت کی سرمایہ کاری ترکی

پاسپورت 2

 

Citizenship Investors in Turkey...

BEWARE the SHARKS.....

Today by chance I did an internet search for 'Citizenship Investment Turkey', and clicked on a few of the advertisements there. I was shocked by the number of new 'practitioners', the number of old 'practitioners' dressed up in new websites to look 'professional', and the number of scam artists that were previously so prolific in misleading British investors buying property in Turkey ten years ago. Some had new names, but were still operating out of the same offices in North London, Covent Garden etc...

I was also shocked by the false and misleading statements being made on websites:

1) In one case I found an example of an agent boldly stating, not just implying, that the 'Certificate of Conformity' an investor receives during the Citizenship application process, confirms that the property is in full legal compiance with all regulations. Nothing could be further from he truth, and the unknowing investor will unfortunately find out the truth much later...

2) The second most popular 'ploy' or 'hoax' is to provide a list of 'APPROVED' properties... they may have been approved by someone for something, but certainly not by any government regulatory authority as an attestation to being in full legal compliance of everything that matters...

Investors, add these two clues to your information gathering exercise... make a list of every 'practitioner' or 'agent' by their name and address, and those that are using the above mentioned false and misleading practices, place a big cross through their names for future reference, so you remember in case you should encounter them again in the future when they may have changed their name, website, and the hoaxes they are peddling...

#citizenship  #investment #Turkey #CIP #scam #hoax #ploys #property #real-estate

Citizenship Investment in Turkey: No Risks but the Investment...

Today’s real estate market in Turkey is being led by the most active source of new buyers. These new buyers are the citizenship investors buying property to obtain a Turkish passport and world-wide tax free income with non-residency status. A very attractive prospect, and a very well designed inward investment program, competitive at the leading edge, globally.

The program is so well designed that the citizenship qualifying criteria are basic and simple, the application submission and disclosure is basic and simple, the application processing is basic and simple, and the delivery of the passport is basic and simple. A non-Turkish speaking applicant obviously will need a Turkish speaking person to follow the application in a periodic manner, as it crosses the different approval stages within the different ministries, but very little can or does go wrong. There are no hidden pitfalls, contingencies, criteria, additionalities. Investors that are overly concerned about this need to rest assured, citizenship application procedures are indeed as simple as described.

The biggest risk is not the application risk. The biggest risk is the investment risk. There are no specific regulations governing business practices applied to foreign investors buying property in Turkey, and consumer protection laws are week compared to most developed  many countries. As a result, estate agents and everyone else, from lawyers to mortgage bankers, are facilitating sharp practices, all driven by ‘gold rush mentality’ in pursuit of exorbitant hidden price mark-ups and commissions.

An example of one of many investors’ grievances illustrates these risks below. What is he complaining about?

• Paying the seller’s transfer taxes and other transaction costs.
• Paying too much for the property.
• Misleading information about urban location.
• Misleading information about local transportation and travel times.
• Misleading information about building surroundings.
• Misleading information about rental income and yields.
• Misleading information about permits
• Misleading information about payments, deposits, procedures etc

Investors would be wise to spend less time and effort on citizenship qualification criteria and application procedures, and instead, allocate more time and effort to finding properties that qualify with complete due diligence. Using professional non-commission charging advisers is the best way to do this, but there are practically none available because of the ‘commission gold fever’. Investors would do well to avoid English speaking websites of estate agents. Ninety percent have inaccurate or misleading information on their web pages, including their ‘advice’ guides on how to buy property in Turkey.  Of the remaining ten percent, a few of these have the longest and most dire track record of misleading foreign investors. One recently told an investor that they do not charge buyers a commission, and at the same time, on the firm’s website, there was a statement assuring investors they do not receive commission from sellers. Knowing this firm does not charge fees, the implication is that they are a charity, working for free.  Exactly what type of investors do they expect to be so gullible as to believe any of what they say…?

Investors be prepared, this type of practice is not uncommon or unusual. Instead it is standard practice by everyone in the ‘gold fever commission’ chain- estate agents, citizenship consultants, lawyers, mortgage bankers, appraisers etc. In private, it is laughed off amongst them as a necessary tactic for remaining competitive in business, and so acceptable. For many, receiving one or two commissions of $20,000 to $40,000 justifies risking their professional licenses, but the chances of recourse through sanction are so low as to be a nonexistent risk.

Caveat emptor is a key tenant of free market economies… ‘buyer beware’ comes with a high risk and cost for the buyer.

#CitizenshipInvestment #Turkey #CitizenshipbyInvestment #PropertyTurkey #RealEstate #Istanbul #Agents #commissions #agents

Property in Turkey: Buyer Beware of Self-Inflicted Injury

Property in Turkey: Buyer Beware of Self-Inflicted Injury….

 

During the last 13+ years more than 70,000 foreigners have purchased property in Turkey….

More than 85% have suffered with difficulties from what happened AFTER the purchase. First it was the British and Northern Europeans; then the Kuwaitis and their complaints resulted in a diplomatic incident; now it’s Citizenship Investors.

 

Official Turkish government agencies have been very proactive in providing solutions. For example, the Office of the President of Turkey has a website dedicated to providing information to guide foreign investors, and several other local agencies have the same. Unfortunately NONE of these websites receive links from the English speaking agents and develops websites (with one exception). Instead, several new websites have sprung up by agents using very similar website names as the government ones: to lure unsuspecting foreigners.

 

So foreigners face some problems when buying property in Turkey, and usually do not find out until after the purchase. To say that the official channels are not very helpful is completely inaccurate. So what is the problem…?

 

The real problem is that many foreign investors prefer to delude themselves, even when they have been told of the risks and problems. Instead of using independent professional advice, they continue to rely on the English language agents’ websites. This leads them to do things they would not do when buying a property in their own country. Perhaps because living in a property all their life, they imagine they know everything necessary to buy one, in a foreign country with an unfamiliar legal and property system.

 

And then there is simple delusion: usually they prefer to take a chance with an agent by convincing themselves it will be all right, all the while knowing they will be paying huge hidden price mark-ups of $20-30,000 instead of paying $2-3000 to a professional advisor in fees. Paying fees to professional advisors is clearly much more difficult for these naive investors, than paying 10 Xs as much in an agent’s hidden price mark-ups. And for that reason the agents continue to do thrive and do business, and the naive foreign investors continue to complain about being ‘ripped off’; but it is a self inflicted injury.

 

Read below how foreign citizenship investor have described their recent experiences;

 

‘---- On Sat, 11 May 2019 13:16:52 +0300 (PersonalDetailsRedacted forPrivacy) wrote ----

 

Its very simple, let me explain my position.

I am looking to buy a property in Turkey for the purpose of Rental Income. I have visited Istanbul back in Nov 2017 and realized the following:

1. Most of the Agents try to see you over priced properties in new developments in  Başakşehir,  Esenyurt,  Avcılar, Buyukcekmece,etc. There are areas far from center and NOT good for rental income. or even resale because no ones going to buy from you when there is an abundance of properties already available direct from constructors ones. I checked later with some of my arab friends and realized they (few ones I know) bought into these areas back in 2013+ and now not able to resell it at all. 
2. The rental income promised to me for some of the properties shown (during my stay in istanbul agents showed me several properties and even projecs like denize istanbul) that I will get 7% Rental Yield and that in 3 years 20% Price appreciation. I later found out from reliable internet europe based sources that the rental yield in turkey is the lowest some where from 2.5% to 3% as NET (after you deduct the rental income tax etc) and that too were for areas like lavent, nisantasi, florya etc. These new dev areas stand no chance near the same figure.  
3. Later in 2018, Lira crashed  (when I visited Istanbul in nov 2017, I cached 1 SAR for 0.95 Lira and now 1 SAR fetches 1.6 Lira) do the math. and see for yourself has the property really appreciated for folks who are foreigners and sending Euros or USD or SAR or AED to buy properties? I feel they will lose their capital even if they are able to resell and bring back the dollar value..

 

  

---- On Sun, 23 Jun 2019 20:27:20 +0300 (PersonalDetailsRedacted forPrivacy) wrote ----

 

Let me make a few statements so you know the background

 

• Based on my one year research and personal visit to Istanbul and understanding, I have opinion that 95% of the agents lie and cheat. In the sense that they will inflate the prices. This is true for either agents or developers. The moment they know you are a foreigner they haunt you and think all foreigners are stupid. So I stay away from such agents. Unfortunately there are no English language folks or depts in Turkey for info gathering so I will need to get a turkish person or company else I could have done all by myself. I am a salaried person but i manager to create a couple of good properties in Dubai completely with my own efforts and now enjoying 6% (it was 9%) net rental yield in Dubai. of course not all properties will give you that . you need to be brutal in your research not to fall for those greedy and cunning agents or builders. there is a whole lot of research involved like the past experience of the builders. how many projects it completed. visiting the completed projects, talking to people there, knowing issues of maintenance, visit forums etc etc. its a hell of a process and i was able to do all for dubai because every one speaks english
• My aim to invest in dubai is twofold. One is to diversify my portfolio as dubai is now down in terms of profit but still better, yet its good idea to diversify and second is to get turkish passport. Of course my main strategy is to use the property for rental income.  am not in for flipping properties. However i should atleast ensure that in 5 years time that i should be able to sell those easily in secondary market. Hence I realized from global property websites that turkey is the lowest in rental incomes; avg 2.5 to 3%. Now all of the agents and developers boasted a lot to me claiming 5 to 8% and thats a big lie. All over world avg rental yield is hardly 3%. Anyway am good to go with 3% net in turkey.
• The new developements claimed in center like maslak or sisili are not exactly in that close. Take for example avengart which is situated up close to the belgard forest. Likewise these new developements are very large in nature with glass walls and all that fancy stuff. maybe appealing to rich arabs --fine. but i doubt i will be able to rent them easily. avengart may have say 500+ units but how many clients will wan to rent? i doubt it. also the example of zorlu i saw so many ads on sahebindan that I am sure 30% of zorlu flats are up for rent -means vacated. Even if am lucky my rentai will be quite low. for exampe the avengart developer says list price 1m but may give upto 900k for cash. In my view this is still over priced and correct price shuld be 700 k
• I sent email to  info@invest.gov.tr who really replied my queries well but they are being political too so no clear answer as well..  They provided me a link emlakkonut.com.tr which does not help much as it has basic info about each property. Then to apply for citizenship, the offics in turkey needs several visits and knwldge of turkey. The avg fee of a lawyer asking is 3250 USD from start to end but the lawyer wont guide me which is best property.
• Other thing i noticed is that some of these developements put up a sign saying we are gvt backed, tapu is ready. now the unit is not handed over but tapu is ready. So i think these agents or companies like avengart have tie up with some agents to process all under the table like getting an assesment report in their favor for the price of property. 
• I did a research on sagenbindan for 1+1 or 2+1 from local market. and concatcted owners or local turkish agents and use google translate to chat on whatsapp and i realize it is MUCH MUCH better to buy a property from secondary market already rented so you know the ROI than going for these new dev projects. But then i need a local turkish expert to negotiate but less price means more rental roi. on the asking price of rents and sell for same properties in areas like levent, nisantase , maslak , gloriya, i found the gross rental yield a 4.1 to 4.3 %. So negotiatate a better price is essential.
• Buying from local means risks. like is tapu real. will govt assess the value correct? is the tenant rent only to sell me as fake etc etc

Hence i asked all of the questions.    ‘

 

 

Unfortunately only about 15% of foreign property buyers use an independent professional advisor: these are usually investors or people from professions like doctors, who understand the value and necessity of expert guidance. The other 85% of buyers seem to think that they can obtain a little advice free from the internet, and that will be enough. What these buyers don’t understand is that agents have many different misleading tactics and deceptions that they use with buyers several times a day, every day, for years. The buyer may be prepared for one tactic, but the agent has many, and will hook the buyer with one of them.

 

No buyer can possibly educate themselves to every trick and ploy. In this situation the buyer can not possibly win. A professional advisorthat has experience dealing with agents’ tricks everyday for years can win.

 

Tags: Buying Property Turkey

#CitizenshipInvestment #Turkey #CitizenshipbyInvestment #PropertyTurkey #RealEstate

Citizenship by Investment in the Amount of $100,000…?

Citizenship by Investment in the Amount of $100,000…?   

Yes it’s possible to obtain Citizenship by Investment in Turkey for less than 

$250,000. This is only possible by applying a technique that utilizes investment 

contracts. 

There are additional risks for the investor with this technique. First, there is the 

risk that the investor will forfeit the amounts invested if the investor misses making

the periodic installment payments. Second, there is the counterparty risk that the

investment becomes insolvent, leading to legal costs, deferred liquidation, and 

potential loss . 

To successfully apply this technique, a higher level of expertise is required for two 

aspects. Firstly, the Risk Assessment of the investment requires detailed Due Diligence 

on the counter-party, cash flows, asset, transaction, and investment contract. This is not 

an investment for an investor that is unfamiliar with any of these concepts.  Second, a 

greater degree of expertise is required for the management of the Citizenship 

application, both at the initial stage, and during the life of the contract.  

All of the above require expert advice that 'drills down’ into  the 

investment in much finer detail than the usual standard investment parameters 

and application management.

Expert advice is essential, and is not widely available. Investors will require a 

professional Risk Assessment, beginning with the transaction methodology, as 

the essential first step. Under no circumstances should the advice be relied upon 

from service providers that handle only the usual investment fund or real estate 

investments, such as stock brokers, real estate agents, generalist lawyers, 

or global citizenship consultants. 

#citizenship-investment-turkey, #CitizenshipInvestmentTurkey

Buying Property in Turkey: Key Facts

Buying a Property in Turkey? The facts are explained here... almost everything you need to know. Provided by the Land Registry Governate of the Republic of Turkey. It has the Facts and is an essential reference guide... 

But what it doesn't tell you may be more important... for that information, click here to get 'The Guide to Buying Property in Turkey a Safer, Smarter, Better Way... ' 

And click here for information about the Key Facts and other Government Publications about Citizenship Investment Program in Turkey, by Property Investment.